The story behind a success always makes for good reading. And, if
such a story is presented like a drama, interspersed with audacious
ambition, envy, struggle for control, rivalry, lawsuits, accusations,
counter-accusations, and some humour, it would most likely make for some
very engrossing reading. To top it all, this is not a work of fiction -
in fact, it is not even a dramatization of reality. It is a chronicle
of events that happened behind the scenes of what in the words of the
author is the 'hottest business, media and technology success of our
time'.
The book starts with describing a scene in 2003, where the
founders of Google, Larry Page and Sergey Brin, address a high school in
Israel. They explain how Google was born.
Page and Brin were PhD
students at Stanford University. The idea of Google was born when Page
conceived of downloading the entire web on to his computer to try and
devise a search program for it. It was an audacious idea. While he had
planned to finish the exercise in a week, he could manage only a portion
of it even after a year. "So, optimism is important," Page told his
audience, "One must have a healthy disregard for the impossible."
It
was this optimism that helped Page persist with his plan. He kept
downloading the web on to his machine, and Brin helped him mine the data
and make sense of it. According to the duo, it took a lot of effort, a
lot of night-outs, and a lot of working through holidays.
After this brief prelude-like beginning, the story goes back to the beginning - when Page met Brin.
Page
and Brin were both PhD students at Stanford, and they had a lot in
common. They were both from families which placed great value on
scholarship and academic excellence. They both had fathers who were
professors, and mothers whose jobs revolved around computers and
technology. Computers, mathematics, and intellectual debates and
discussions were part of their genetic codes as well as their day-to-day
lives. It was only natural, then, that they got along with each other
quite well, and started working together.
They also had an
environment that was very conducive to innovation, experimentation and
ideation. Stanford is known for churning out several successful
technology ventures, including HP and Sun (Sun stands for Stanford
University Network). People in Stanford are firm in their belief that
sometimes, making a business out of a technological innovation delivers a
much greater effect than writing a paper on it.
Also, at the time
the two were together, there was a major IT revolution happening. The
likes of Netscape were creating waves outside with unprecedentedly huge
IPO's, and the Internet was touted to be the next big thing. As a
result, venture capitals were skewed heavily towards funding
technological start-ups. These circumstances created a setting ripe for
research and innovation relating to the Internet, and Page and Brin
believed that a robust search application was the one thing that
Internet users most needed.
Search engines prevalent at that time
provided service that was far from satisfactory. There were many in
operation - the likes of Lycos, Webcrawler, Excite and a few others. All
of them fell short. They would only display a slew of results that made
little sense to the searcher.
At that time, another duo from
Stanford was running a company which they had named 'Yahoo'. They
devised a better search algorithm, by creating an alphabetized directory
of Web Pages. Also, another new search engine called AltaVista came up.
Its search algorithm was based, like other search engines, on the
number of times the key word figured in the web page, but it displayed
results using the now popular concept of web links. A link, essentially,
is a kind of a pointer to another web page.
The idea of using links for a search engine excited Brin and Page. They started thinking of it on an entirely new dimension.
Coming
from families that treasured academic research, Page and Brin looked at
links as something akin to citations in academic research. In academia,
a paper was considered good if it had citations. The more the
citations, the better the paper. Also, not all citations were equal.
Citations from quality sources enhanced the paper's value.
Using
the analogy, the pair developed their search algorithm, called PageRank.
It depended, among other things, the number of links that pointed to
the web page. The more the links, the higher the rank. Also, links from
the more renowned websites, such as Yahoo, would carry more weight than a
link from a lesser known website.
Initially, the Google Guys
named their search engine 'BackRub', as it was based on the links
pointing backward to the site. However, they eventually decided that
they had to come up with a new name. Because it dealt with vast amounts
of data, they decided to name it 'Google'. Googol is a very large number
- 1 followed by 100 zeros. 'Google', is actually a misspelling of
'Googol', something which many people do not know.
Google was
first released internally in Stanford. From the beginning, it has
maintained a clean and simple homepage, free from flashy animations and
the like. It was an instant hit in the Stanford network.
As their
database grew, Brin and Page needed more hardware. As they were short of
cash, they bought inexpensive parts and assembled them themselves. They
also tried all they could to get their hands on unclaimed machines.
They did everything they could to keep their hardware cost at a minimum.
Initially,
the duo attempted to sell Google to other major web companies like
Yahoo and AltaVista. However, both companies could not accept Google,
because, among other reasons, they did not believe that search was a
vital part of the Web experience.
In the initial days, the Google
guys were not sure of the business model. They did not know just how
Google could make money. The motto of the company was 'Don't be evil'.
They believed that advertisements on web pages were evil, and hence
wanted to avoid having ads on their webpages. They were hopeful that in
the future, other websites would want to use their search engine, and
they could profit by charge these websites. They were also relying
purely on word-of-mouth for their marketing. They did not advertise at
all.
Google's database kept growing, and they started buying more
hardware and recruiting more people. Initially, Google was funded by a
$1 million investment by an angel investor named Andy Bechtolsheim.
Eventually, though, they ran out of it, and needed more money.
They
did not want to go public and raise money like many other companies
did, for they had no intentions of letting their information go public,
and they also wanted to have full control over the company. The only
option, then, seemed to be to approach venture capitalists. The duo was
convinced that they could get VC's to fund them, and at the same time
continue to retain their control over the company.
They approached
two VC companies, Sequoia and Kleiner Perkins. Both companies were
impressed with the idea, and were ready to fund Google. However, because
they did not want to give up control, the Google guys demanded that
both companies invest jointly in Google.
In Wall Street, two major
VC companies would hardly consent to a joint investment in a fledgling
firm owned by a couple of unrelenting youngsters. However, due to the
inherent attractiveness and workability of their idea, and through help
from some of their contacts, the Google guys pulled off a coup that was
unheard of. They got the two companies to invest $25 million each, and
they still retained full control of Google. The only condition that the
two VC's placed was to hire an experienced industry person to manage
their business. The Google guys agreed, hoping that they could push such
an appointment to as late a date as possible.
As Google
progressed, several improvements came up. The now famous Google Doodle -
an image that appears in the Google homepage to signify an important
event or to honour a person - started out as a signal to employees that
Brin and Page were away. When Brin and Page went to a party called
Burning Man, they left an image of a burning man in the homepage to
signal to employees that they were away. After this, they experimented
with replacing the two O's of Google with Halloween pumpkins, to signify
the festival of Halloween. It was an instant hit with Google's users.
Since then, the logo is often decorated with a doodle to signify or
honour important occasions/landmarks/persons.
Google started
recruiting people for specific roles. There was an employee dedicated to
making doodles, and another to polishing and improving user design.
Significantly, they recruited Dr.Jim Reese of Harvard to manage
operations. His responsibility was to ensure that Google's burgeoning
hardware requirements were consistently met. Since Google saves a lot of
money by buying cheap computers and assembling them themselves, it was
important that they be maintained, monitored and managed properly. To
ensure reliability, Dr.Reeves spread data over several computers,
managed them all from a central system, and used redundancy to insure
the company against system crashes. By minimizing hardware costs, and
using free to use Linux based operating systems over expensive ones like
Windows, Google had earned for itself a major cost advantage.
Google
got more and more popular. It won the support and admiration of Danny
Sullivan, editor of an influential newsletter focused on Internet
search. It had built for itself a very loyal user base that gave
feedback on even the slightest of modifications to the site. However, it
had yet to come up with a way of making money.
At that time, a
company called Overture caught Brin's attention. Overture was the
company that provided the search results that accompanied searches of
Yahoo and AOL, among others. The Google guys liked the idea of having
ads based on search, rather than flashy and distracting banner ads.
However, there was one practice of Overture's that they did not approve
of - Overture guaranteed that if a company paid a certain amount of
money, it would find a place among the advertisements. It went directly
against their motto of 'Don't be evil'.
They decided, therefore,
to go it alone. They developed an algorithm for search-based advertising
on their own. True to their motto, they ensured that there was a clear
demarcation between the actual search results and the advertisements.
Like the search results, the advertisements, too, would be ranked. The
ranking of the advertisements would be based not only on the amount of
money paid, but also on the number of times it is clicked. Hence,
popular ads would appear more prominently.
Prices for Google's ads
were fixed through a nonstop auctioning process. Auctions were done for
every search phrase. A phrase like 'investment advice' would cost a lot
more than a phrase like 'pet food'. Companies started having dedicated
employees to carry out Google auctions. There were several subtleties
involved. For instance, 'digital cameras' would be auctioned for a
higher rate than 'digital camera', because a user googling 'digital
cameras' is more likely to buy one.
Google advertising policy was
not without its share of problems. Once, an insurance company named
Geico filed a lawsuit against Google, on the grounds that it had allowed
other companies to bid for its name. A user searching for 'Geico' would
see in his results all insurance companies that had made a winning bid
for it. Geico claimed that Google did not have a right to let Geico's
competition take advantage of searches on its name. Google's defense was
that Geico's understanding of consumer behavior on the Internet was
incorrect. A user googling 'Geico' is not necessarily looking only at
Geico's website. Besides, Google was not the publisher of the ads, and
it also had systems in place to protect trademarks. It did not allow ads
to contain trademarks in their heading or text. Google ended up winning
the case.
It has also been alleged that Google's naming of the
advertisement section 'Sponsored Links' misleads many users. Many users
confuse ads with actual results, and click on them without even knowing
they are ads. The ethicality of this lack of clear distinction has often
come under question.
With the business model set straight,
innovation and new ideas flourished at Google's expanded office, called
the Googleplex. One employee came up with the idea of retrieving a
person's phone number if his name and zip code are entered. Another came
up with the idea of auto-correcting spelling mistakes. If, for
instance, you misspell a celebrity's name, Google would automatically
correct it and display search results for the corrected name. If a less
obvious mistake is made, Google comes up with a "Did you mean...?" link
at the top of the page.
Google also launched its Google Image
Search, which again was revolutionary. Millions of images are stored in
Google's database and can be retrieved at the click of a mouse.
The
Google guys created an infrastructure and a culture inside the
Googleplex that would make employees want to stay there for most part of
the day - and night. Mean as they were with spending on computer
hardware, they spent unrestrainedly when it came to creating the right
environment for their employees. There were free meals, unlimited
snacks, toys, roller hockey, scooter races, and lots more. Even the
buses were equipped with Wi-Fi Internet connectivity, so that employees
could be productive even while they commuted.
External happenings
also helped Google. The dotcom crash of 2000 left several extremely
talented software developers unemployed, giving Google access to a vast
talent pool. Also, around that time, Microsoft was facing a legal
dispute regarding its anti-competitive practices. This made the image of
Microsoft take a beating. Google, with its 'Don't be evil' motto,
suddenly overtook Microsoft as the ultimate place for a software
developer to be in. The creme-de-la-crème of the software profession
started preferring to work in Google.
Google also actively
encouraged and fostered innovation inside the Googleplex. Employees were
free to spend 20% of their time on innovative tasks that interested
him. They did not have to worry about whether it could be made
profitable, or have any fear about its acceptance or workability. They
could so just work on anything that was of interest to them. Ideas were
often discussed in bulletin boards and over lunch. As an idea grew, it
would get bigger and bigger. Google also provided the resources to carry
out innovation. Out of this culture were born several ideas. An avid
reader of news came up with an idea of providing users with multiple
sources of news clustered together, to help them analyze and understand
news better. Thus was born Google news. Interestingly, unlike Google
search results, the Google news results are cramped close together. This
denseness is intended to give the user as much news as possible.
Ranking is based on relevance, and also the source. Another innovation
was Froogle, later renamed Google Product search, which helped users
search for retail products to shop.
Google soon became a verb in
several languages, including English, German, and Japanese. A lot of
debates about Google were triggered. With information on people only a
Google search away, there were issues related to online stalking of
individuals. Google's advertisements, despite the company's checks,
included certain obscene websites. In academia, the use of Google by
students in preference to the classically used specialized databases was
looked at, on one hand, as increasingly easy and wide access to
information, and on the other hand, looked down as a shortcut method
that fostered laziness.
For all its popularity, Google hardly
spent on advertising. Marketing happened only through word-of-mouth.
Google kept its homepage clean and free of ads, foregoing millions of
dollars of revenue. It avoided a graphics-heavy homepage which would
slow down retrieving search results. It focused on getting users fast
results, unlike other sites which wanted users to stay on their
respective pages for as long as possible. It did not have a user lock-in
- there was no need to register to be able to use Google search. By
offering a superior product aimed primarily at satisfying the user,
Google had eliminated any need for advertising. The only promotion it
did was through selling caps and T-shirts with the Google logo.
Google
launched a new program, to be able to pull users towards Google rather
than just wait for them to find Google. Under this program, any website
could register to use the Google search box in its page. Called the
affiliate program, it promised to pay websites 3 cents for every search
that they added to Google. Google, would, of course, earn from ad
revenue.
Ever since they had got funded by the two VC firms, the
Google guys had been under constantly increasing pressure to hire a CEO
who would manage the business aspects of the company. Google had crossed
the threshold beyond which a company was required to go public, and the
VC firms were particular about having an experienced business
professional as the public face of the company before it went public.
Several candidates were sent to Brin and Page by the Venture
Capitalists, but none of them managed to please the Google guys.
As
pressure mounted and time kept running out, Eric Schmidt, CEO of the
software company Novell, stepped into the Googleplex to meet Brin and
Page. He had consented to see them only because of the insistence of top
people from one of the VC firms, a good relationship with whom he knew
was important. He had no interest in the meeting at all. The Google guys
were equally uninterested in meeting him. They were expecting another
of the dull and boring kind of which they had already seen many.
When
Schmidt entered, his biography was projected against the wall, and his
strategy at Novell was openly criticized. Schmidt argued back
vehemently, and there started a heated debate that went on for a long
time. After he left, Schmidt realized that he had not had an
intellectual debate of that kind in a long time. Brin and Page, too,
found Schmidt to be refreshingly different from the rest of the
candidates they had interviewed. The Venture Capital people knew that
Schmidt could do the deft balancing act of giving a business structure
and direction to the company, while at the same time ensuring that the
freedom that Brin and Page so wanted remained unaffected.
Soon,
Eric Schmidt was made CEO of Google. He put all his experience into play
and acted most maturely. He knew when to push, when to agree, when to
back off, and when to argue. He still gave the Google guys a lot of
leeway. He realized that they had created in Google a culture of
innovation which it would be unwise to tamper with. All he intended to
do was to build a business and management structure around the strategy
and the culture that Brin and Page had so meticulously built.
There
were, of course, points of disagreement between Schmidt and the Google
guys. It took a lot of convincing from Schmidt to persuade Brin and Page
into appreciating that the payroll system of the company, which was
based on free software, needed an overhaul. Schmidt wanted to purchase
packaged software of Oracle, which he believed was a necessity, given
Google's size and rate of expansion. Brin and Page, however, did not see
any merit in paying thousands to Oracle when free software was
available.
There were also cases when Brin and Page had their way
stubbornly. There was once a violent bidding war going on between Google
and Overture over AOL's search business. Google eventually won it by
offering AOL guarantees amounting to millions of dollars. Schmidt was
worried about this, as the company's cash balance was fast shrinking.
Brin and Page, however, went on with the deal, as they firmly believed
that search and search-related advertising with a company like AOL was
well worth the risk. Eventually, it turned out to be the right decision.
This
apart, Google also inked a deal with Yahoo to provide its search
results. It also signed a $100 million deal with AskJeeves.com, a
competitor, to provide it with search-based advertising. It showed
maturity and confidence on Google's part to get into deals with
competitors.
In April 2004, Google promised to launch an email
service which it promised would be markedly superior to existing email
services. Brin and Page knew that, with the abundance of email service
providers already functioning, a new email service had to be
significantly superior to be able to succeed. Google Mail, or Gmail,
they believed, was significantly superior.
Gmail's unique features
included easy retrievability through a Google-like search of emails, 1
GB of free storage, which was several times the storage space of
existing email service providers, and a unique way of representing a
series of emails, resembling a conversation. Gmail was first given to
1000 opinion leaders for testing. They could then give Gmail to a
limited number of people on an Invite basis. This gave Gmail a kind of
exclusivity which made it a much desired item.
However, just as
all seemed to be going well, Gmail ran into troubles. Google had planned
to have ads in Gmail similar to those in Google. The ads would be
context-specific, based on the content of the email. This announcement
led to a hue and cry among privacy groups. Law suits were threatened and
there were calls to close down Gmail. The issue was with the scanning
of emails. It was felt that by reading every email, Google was
infringing on the privacy of individuals. It was also feared that
security issues might arise because of the huge storage space and the
subsequent long retention period of emails.
Google's clean
reputation till then took a beating for the first time. The timing could
not have been worse, as Google was soon to go public. Brin and Page,
who were expecting positive reception for what they believed was a
superior product, were taken aback. They hoped that the protests were
only a passing cloud, and that things would settle down soon. They
clarified that the scanning of emails was automated, and that they would
not be informed about the content. They explained that every email
service provider scanned emails for displaying emails itself, and for
detecting viruses.
As time passed and more and more users started
using Gmail, they started finding the experience highly satisfying. The
bad publicity started dying down slowly, and Gmail eventually became a
big hit.
When the time came for Google to go public, Brin and Page
wanted to play it their way, again. A typical IPO in USA is done with
the help of big investment banks. These banks do the publicity with the
help of what is called a road show, help price the stock, and guarantee a
minimum amount to the issuing company. However, there was a conflict in
the goals of the investment bank and the issuing company. While the
investment bank would want the stock to be underpriced, so that it rises
in value and favoured investors gain. The company, on the other hand,
would want the price to be as high as possible, so as to raise the
maximum possible amount.
Google did not want investment banks to
call the shots. They were ready to pay only half the price investment
banks usually demanded, and they wanted to dictate terms in the IPO.
They wanted the IPO to be egalitarian - anyone could invest. The minimum
number of shares was only 5. Pricing would be based on an auction, just
like Google ads. They felt that the road shows unfairly divulged
information only to a select few. To make things fair, they released all
relevant information on the Internet, for everyone to see.
Also, to retain control, they issued two classes of shares - Class A
and Class B. Class A shares were for regular investors, carrying one
vote each. Class B shares were for themselves, carrying ten votes each,
and giving them absolute control.
As the date of stock issue
neared, skepticism started arising regarding Google's stock. The price
band - $110-$135, about 150 times its per share earnings, started being
seen as too high. It was feared that after the stock issue, employees of
Google would exercise their stock options and leave the company. To
make things worse, Playboy magazine released an informal and very casual
interview of Brin and Page. It was an interview taken a lot earlier,
but was timed to cash in on all the publicity surrounding Google.
Besides being a violation of SEC rules, it also sowed seeds of doubt in
potential investors' mind about the seriousness of the guys at the top
of Google's hierarchy.
Google's venture capitalists, who had a lot
at stake, had to step in. It was decided that the Playboy article would
be attached as appendix to Google's registration documents, to
circumvent the violation of the quiet period. Also, the venture
capitalists decided to hold back all Google stock they had planned to
sell - a signal that they expected the stock price to increase. Finally,
Google's IPO was completed and the stock went out at $85 per share. It
currently trades at $530 per share.
Google kept going from
strength to strength. It won AOL's European business almost from under
Yahoo's nose, buy offering AOL million dollar guarantees after Yahoo had
nearly consummated a deal with AOL. The deal was made by Sergey Brin.
Sergey Brin's responsibilities mainly involved making deals, cutting
costs, and handling issues relating to culture and motivation. Larry
Page, on the other hand, was involved more in hands-on work. He also
supervised hiring of employees, and identified innovative projects that
showed most potential. Eric Schmidt, the CEO, for his part, took care of
operations. He ensured that projects were on schedule, and that
deadlines were met. He also looked after the finance, accounting, and
other systems.
Innovations kept coming. Google Suggest guessed
what you wanted to search. Google desktop gave a comprehensive search
solution for your PC. Google video search and Google satellite map came
up. Google Scholar was introduced to help search for scholarly articles.
The list just kept getting longer.
In between all this, Google
started out on an ambitious project to digitize all books in leading
libraries and make them available to Google users. Starting with the
University of Michigan, a few libraries were selected. Books were
scanned using technology that was gentle on the books, and did not
affect them. After scanning, these books would be made available in a
form which would not allow copying. For books still in copyright, users
would be able to view only snippets of pages.
To win the support
of publishers, Google came up with a compelling value proposition. It
would cover the costs of scanning and indexing books in return for the
right to be able to show them in its search results. It would then
present them in a form which would not allow copying. It would also
provide direct links to booksellers, from whom the book could be bought.
Thus, Google was, in effect, giving the user a flavor of the book's
content and enticing him to purchase it. It eventually got support from
publishers. The project was named Google Books.
In the future, we
might see Google use its massive computing power to help research in the
field of genetics. Already, Google has downloaded a map of the human
genome, and is exploring possibilities with biologists. Millions of
genes, combined with loads of biological and scientific data form a
combination which only a system of Google's power, processing capacity,
and storage space can execute.
The book is exceedingly well
written. From the beginning, and till the end, the author makes sure
that the reader is kept interested and enthralled. And he does so by
using no dramatization whatsoever. By just sequencing events logically,
occasionally switching focus to ancillary characters, and by simply
describing articulately how the Google phenomenon unfolded, the author
gives the reader every reason to keep reading the book. The characters
of Larry Page and Sergey Brin are sketched beautifully. The book is
written like a novel, so the reader never gets bored. The author should
also be given credit for his neutrality. While he is generous in his
praise for Google in general and its founders in particular, he is also
critical of them on occasions, such as their unseemly interview to
Playboy.
On the flip side, the author sometimes goes to a level of
detail that tests the reader's patience, such as the detailed
description of the Burning Man Festival. Also, certain characters, such
as Charlie Ayers, the chef, are given undue importance. While it is
understandable that the chef's stay at Google created an entirely new
food culture and helped motivate employees, dedicating an entire chapter
to him and including one of his recipes in it are neither necessary nor
justified.
On the whole, the Google story takes you on a journey -
a journey in time of the biggest Internet success story till date. It
is a journey that will keep you engrossed, and it is one you will enjoy.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)
Did you know you can create short urls with Shortest and get cash for every visit to your short links.
ReplyDelete